Gobies: Going, Going, Gone?
A WebQuest for 6-8th Grade (Science)
Designed by Loris Chen (lchen@wyckoffschools.org)
|  |
| Pandaka
pygmaea |
Introduction
Task
Process
Evaluation
Conclusion
Credits
Introduction
You are part of a team of specialists
whose mission is to determine the best way to preserve two
species of goby. Your team has been invited to make a presentation
at an international conference where other teams will be
competing for project funding. Will your presentation
earn your project funding?
The Task
The populations of two species of gobies may be declining.
Pandaka pygmaea, the world’s smallest vertebrate,
was added to the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species in
1996 and may have already become extinct. Sinarapan
(Mistichthys luzonenesis) is the smallest commercially
harvested fish. Fishermen have reported a decreasing number
of Sinarapan. Edible goby species are economically important
to many parts of the Philippines where small-scale fisheries
are the primary source of income. The decreasing population
of goby species is of great concern to those who rely on
them for an income. These tiny fish are also an important
source of protein in the diets of local people.
Your task is to:
- find out what has caused the decline in the goby population
in the Philippines
- investigate methods for reversing the population trend
- present a proposal that will increase and sustain goby
populations so that they do not become threatened, endangered,
or extinct
Your presentation must include graphics and visual organizers.
Presentations may be in the form of PowerPoint or overhead
projector transparencies.
The Process
Your team will:
- research the biology of two species of goby
- research the geographic distribution of the two species
of goby
- research the human uses of the two species of goby
- research sustainable habitat preservation methods
- develop a plan to study the effect of one sustainable
method
- create a presentation to secure funding for your study
Divide the tasks 1 though 4 among your group members so
that each person has one research task. Work
together to complete tasks 5 and 6.
Task 1. The Biology of Mistichthys luzonensis
and Pandaka pygmaea
The Question: Why are the populations of these
two species of goby so sensitive to current fishing practices?
Explore what’s known about these two species by entering
the scientific names at Fishbase
and for more information Pandaka
pygmaea. Then read about Sinarapan.
To find out more about why Sinarapan are threatened go to
One
Ocean and scroll to the section titled “World’s
smallest fish endangered.”
Task 2. Geographic Distribution of Mistichthys
luzonensis and Pandaka pygmaea
The Question: Where are these two species
of goby found?
Create a map showing the geographic distribution of these
two species by entering the species name at the OBIS
Portal. At the portal, enter the scientific name
of the sea horse you will be mapping. Select "all
databases." When the database search is complete,
select "map geographic location." Once the
map appears, you may change its orientation by using the
menu below the map.
To find the names of the location where these species have
been collected, use the scientific name search at Fishbase.
How does geography explain the occurrence of the species?
What geography related factors have influenced survival
of these species? Find out about Mangrove
habitats in the Philippines.
Task 3. Human uses of Mistichthys luzonensis
and Pandaka pygmaea
The Question: What uses do humans have for
these small goby species?
To learn more about human uses of Sinarapan read “The
World’s Smallest Commercial Fish.”
Task 4. Sustainable Habitat Management
The Question: What are some possible sustainable
strategies for habitat management?
Find out what is being done to restore habitat in freshwater
systems and action
being taken in the Philippines. What is the status
of mangrove
habitat in the Philippines?
Task 5. The Plan
Since you are a team of research scientists, your plan
will need the following parts:
- Research question- State in question that your
research project will answer.
- Background information- Provide information that
someone would need to know in order to understand your
plan. Be sure to cite sources of information.
This is the place to put information about goby biology,
geographic distribution, human uses of gobies, and sustainable
habitat management methods.
- Hypothesis- A statement that describes the expected
outcome of your project
- Materials- What you will need to conduct
your research or implement your project and why these
are essential
- Procedure- List the steps you would take to conduct
your research
- Why your team thinks the plan will work- Link
this to goby survival and sustainability of the goby populations.
Show a cause and effect relationship.
Task 6. The Presentation
Now it's time to sell your plan. There's only so
much money to go around. Will your presentation convince
the foundation to fund your plan? Your presentation
should include all the elements of your team's plan. Use
visual aids. These might include maps, pictures, charts,
tables, and/or an outline of key points. The presentation
may be done use a computer-based presentation program or
overhead transparencies.
Each person should be responsible for presenting at least
one part of the plan.
Evaluation
Your score for this project will be 40% based on your individual
research notes and 60% based on the group's plan and presentation.
| |
Beginning
1-10 |
Developing
11-20 |
Accomplished
21-30 |
Exemplary
31-40 |
Score |
|
Research Notes
(Maximum 40 points) |
Notes are cut and paste
copies from websites. |
Notes have some organization.
Notes reflect original writing. Notes may or may not
have source citations. |
Notes are organized.
Notes reflect original writing. Partial understanding
is apparent. Notes have source citations. |
Notes are organized as
questions and answers. Understanding is apparent.
Notes reflect original writing. Notes have source
citations. |
|
| |
Beginning
1-8 |
Developing
9-16 |
Accomplished
17-24 |
Exemplary
24-32 |
Score |
| The Plan
(Maximum 32 points) |
Plan is partially complete
or has a weak background section and/ or weak plan.
Poor use of factual information. |
Plan has all elements.
Explanation of why the plan will work is weak. Cause
and effect may not be clear. |
Plan has all the elements.
Elements have a logical flow. Some elements could
be stronger. Citations may be incomplete. |
Plan has all the elements.
Elements have a logical flow. Citations are included
and correct. Cause and effect is clear. |
|
| |
Beginning
1-7 |
Developing
8-14 |
Accomplished
15-21 |
Exemplary
22-28 |
Score |
| The Presentation
(Maximum 28 points) |
Presentation notes are
read. Graphics weakly support the speech. |
Presentation is complete,
but has some weaknesses. Graphics may support the
speaker, but may have some errors or lack of relevance. |
Presentation is complete.
Speakers demonstrate knowledge of the problem and
can clearly state the cause and effect relationship.
Graphics support the speaker. |
Speakers demonstrate
knowledge of the problem and an understanding of the
cause and effect to be studied. Graphics support the
speaker. The speaker sells the plan using good speech
techniques such as eye contact, vocal projection,
and enunciation. |
|
Conclusion
Conservation of a species is complicated by human needs
and wants for products that use those species. Sustainability
is the concept that current needs may be met without sacrificing
the ability of future generations to meet their needs.
What human needs or wants are met by the harvesting
of gobies? What where some of the economic considerations
that you needed to understand? What where some of
the cultural considerations that you needed to understand?
What actions can you personally take to save the habitat?
What actions could your class take to save the habitat?
The World
Land Trust is supporting habitat restoration research
in the Philippines.
Credits & References
Seahorse picture from www.fishbase.org.
Based on a template from
The
WebQuest Page |